Field & Stream may receive financial compensation for products purchased through this site. That is why I own a Rem 788 in 6MM and a Ruger 77 in .257 … Ballistic Tip, 100 gr. The actual range at which the Roberts … First of all, congratulations on narrowing it down that far. The .257 Roberts is just as good, however, both the .250-3000 Savage and the .257 Roberts are somewhat passe. And the .243 will be a little easier on the shoulder after a long afternoon of shooting at varmints. If you like the idea of a 257 Roberts … I consider the Roberts more on a par with the Creedmoor than the 243. However, this rifle caliber doesn't just stop there. The 6 Best Big-Game Loads for the .308 Winchester, How to Hunt Ducks in a Winter Storm and Live to Tell About It, The Story Behind the World-Record Whitetail Deer, The Agony, and Utter Joy, of One Child’s First Fish, The 10 Best Long-Range Hunting Cartridges, Kansas Teenager Tags World-Record Whitetail Buck, How to Pick the Best All-Purpose Deer Rifle, Pro Fly-Tying Tips to Save Time and Fill Boxes. Here in Iowa I don’t get to use it as much as I would like, but when Iowa had the special late antlerless centerfire season a couple of years back this rifle hit like Thor’s hammer with hand-loaded 120-grain Nolser Partions, on top of 70 grains of Rl-25 powder. Remington's marketing … But in the end, shot placement will trump all. The bore diameter of the .257 Roberts … Big-game hunters in the western states use … I have a 18 year old Ruger Mark I Varmint Special in .243 While .243 is not the best caliber for shooing groundhogs, it is the most available groundhog caliber in gunshops around here. While not quite as popular as the .243 Winchester, the .257 Roberts has certainly earned its stripes over the years. 4. Anyway, if you want my choice of the two, I would go with the 243, unless I just found a rifle chambered in a 257 that I couldn't live without. 243 vs. 257 Roberts? 243 Winchester Load Data; 6mm Remington Load Data; 243 Win Super Short Magnum (WSSM) Load Data; 240 Weatherby Magnum Load Data; 250-3000 Savage Load Data; 257 Roberts Load Data; 257 Roberts Ackley Improved Load Data; 25 Winchester Super Short Magnum Load Data; 25-06 Remington Load Data; 257 … I think your going to have a much better selection of different brands and bullet weights with a 243 than the 257 though. Today’s gunfight pits a couple of smallish deer calibers against each other in a pair of bolt-action deer rifles. I’m not sure I am ready to give up my .270 and .308, but the .243 sure is fun to shoot. Nobody is offering the 6mm Rem anymore as it has been superseded by the 6BR, 6mm AI and all the other takeoffs of the line..257 Roberts and the 6MM are niche calibers and getting rare. All rights reserved. 243 is a lot easier to get ammo for. The .257 would be a little better for deer because it shoots a little heavier round. Loads were also worked up for the .257 Roberts … If you are experiencing difficulties posting in the Buy/Sell/Trade subforums of TFL, please read the "sticky" announcement threads at the top of the applicable subforum. Ruger has the only .257 Roberts I know of in their M77 Ultra Light. This is a .243 Ruger M77 with a tang safety, red recoil pad, and a Redfield 3x9. Partition, or the 110 gr. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. AccuBond would be our … So your question is posed backwards. The.244 … The .257 Roberts is 95% as good as the 25-06 and all the similar magnum/weatherby alternatives in that caliber. .243 continues to sell well throughout Europe, Africa, Australia, and New Zealand. As far as deer hunting calibers go, the .243 is light, small and perfect for beginning deer hunters. In the short action realm,the 308 Winchester is 'underbore,243 Winchester is 'overbore',7mm-08 is about as close to ideal for the 08 case. Gun Fight Friday: .257 vs .243. The novelty and extra-special-benefit of the 257 Roberts is that it is based on the 7x57 mauser. In a short action, it has the potential for a suitable youth rifle but without care towards optimizing hand loads, can lack the power with many 117 … But us westerners often put a premium on that. Roberts that I hand load for in a ruger now and it does not shoot well; been playing with it for a couple of years. 95 or 100 grains through the .243 is the minimum weight for deer (IMO), and the heavier round of the .257 (even if only a little heavier by 20 grains or … This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. Reader Submitted. If you have a firearm related question, please register and post it on the forums. How bout a 25-06? To test the powder using Alliant data, handloads were developed for the .243 and .308 Winchesters. I bought it last year to give my shoulder a rest and shot a 6-point whitetail in southwest Oklahoma with it. 257 Roberts could do very well with a 24" barrel for a lot of reasons. I use the 85-grain Sierra HPBT on smaller deer as well as coyotes; most folks prefer 100-grain bullets. I find my 24" on my Nosler M48 TGR 7mm-08 just perfect as the 24" barrel really balances out the handling of the M48 … Copyright © 2020 Field & Stream. Looking at the table above, it immediately becomes apparent that the .25-06 Remington is ballistically superior to the .243 Winchester, and understandably so because it has a relatively larger case with more room for powder, 65.8 grains vs… They ran high twist barrels way back then. Sorry for getting off the topic, but it seems to be great in both areas. My two cents on this would be get EITHER: I would prefer the .243, for the aforementioned ammo availability and its flatter trajectory. Unless you are going to become a professional pronghorn antelope hunter, .257 Roberts will kill every deer in Georgia. Vote and comment below, and keep the gun pictures coming to fsgunnuts@gmail.com. The deer ran 60 yards, and that was that. It’s the Remington 700 rifle chambered in .257 Weatherby my father gave me as a 16th birthday present. .243 will do the job on deer ,I have seen people take elk with a .243 . If you don't reload, or don't feel the need to reload, there is a much bigger selection of 243 factory ammo than there is for the 257 Roberts and 243 is likely to be much less expensive and much more common … It is a great, low recoil, smooth option. .257 WBY is just silly expensive to shoot and has excessive barrel wear. With hand-loaded 115 grain Nosler ballistic tips, it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other. The old Savage 99 was the last rifle chambered for this caliber and sadly the excellent 99 is no longer being made. IMO, for varmints, the .243 is the better of the two. It is sad the state of factory ammo for the Roberts but loaded properly the 243 sucks hind tit to the Roberts. Although it can smack deer all day long, the 6mm bullet just does not have as much penetrating ability as the .257 caliber bullet of same weight. The .257 Roberts, also known as .257 Bob, is a medium-powered .25 caliber cartridge.It has been described as the best compromise between the low recoil and flat trajectory of smaller calibers such as the .22 and 6mm, and the strong energy but not the strong recoil of larger popular hunting calibers, such as the 7mm family and the popular .30-06.. The.257 Roberts is a low recoiling, mild powered cartridge. It was 110 yard heart shot. In Florida, you would be well served with the 'Roberts, and it might just well do almost everything you need down there. If you're even considering the .257 Roberts you might as well throw the 6mm Remington in the mix. If you are a TFL member and can access TFL, please do not use this link; instead, use the forums (like Questions, Suggestions, and Tech Support) or PM an appropriate mod or admin. The Alliant website lists load data for 22 different cartridges from .223 WSSM to .338 Winchester Magnum. I suppose I'd pick the .243 for deer and varmints, for the ammo availability. Either the 100 gr. Many products featured on this site were editorially chosen. Ned Roberts took the 7x57mm case and necked it down to … GunBlue examines the history of the incomparable .257 Roberts. I plan on taking it to North Dakota this winter when I go to see family and see how well Sweet Sixteen will do on big Northern ‘yotes. No less an authority than Jack O'Connor held that the.257 Roberts was a better, more … I don't think the deer are going to know the difference in the two if you hit them right. A handloader can use bullets in the 55- to 85-grain range. I’m not one to give inanimate objects names but there are exceptions: this is my rifle Sweet Sixteen. Thread starter grouper sandwich; Start date Jan 16, 2008; Prev. Most sporting good stores and walmarts still carry it and probably will continue to carry it. So that leaves the .243 … Mannlicher-Schoenauer MCA .243 Winchester GI#: 101476152 Steyr Mannlicher MCA in .243 Win with 23 inch barrel featuring a barrel band front ramp style sight with gold blade and a rear sight with one fixed … If you still feel you are qualified to post in those subforums, please contact "Shane Tuttle" (the mod for that portion of TFL) via Private Message for assistance. They've proved their lethality on deer sized game wherever these animals are hunted. Both th 25 cal and the 6.5 have never gained the following that they deserve except in 6.5 Creedmoor . .257 ammo can be hard to find in some stores. Designed in 1968, the Ruger M77 is heavy-duty and rugged gun. ... 257 roberts vs 22 250, 257 roberts vs … The .257 Roberts might have a slight advantage for mule deer at longer ranges with 120gr pills. You will probably have a better selection of rifles that manufacture the 243 than the 257 as well. Winchester struck first with the .243 Winchester, followed by the .244 Remington (the .257 Roberts 57mm case necked down) and the .244 Holland & Holland Magnum in the U.K.; all will get the … Re: .257 Roberts vs … This email link is to reach site administrators for assistance, if you cannot access TFL via other means. To each his own, but loading .257 … Copyright Complaints: Please direct DMCA Takedown Notices to the registered agent. .257 Roberts . I am a big .243 fan. Of course there is going to be a better selection of ammo for a 243, but I don't think your going to have a hard time finding ammo for the 257 either. But have been considering building a .257 Roberts … 257 Roberts has faded in popularity largely because of limited positive press over the years. All you need to do is take a Mauser and rebarrel it and you have a correctly feeding 257 roberts. Like the others have already said, I think it's more of a personal preference more than anything. It shoots 1-inch groups at 100 yards, with about any 100-grain bullet. Have a 257 . BALLISTIC ANALYSIS. 257 Roberts is a sweet round, very much overlooked. First the 257 Roberts , it’s a necked down 7x57 ( … This is a .243 Ruger M77 with a tang safety, red recoil pad, and a Redfield 3x9. Such emails will be ignored. In fact no one is chambering a commercially available .250-3000 Savage anymore. A Bonnier Corporation Company. Go. Please note, the following information … 1; 2; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page. Meanwhile, although I declared the EKR of the .257 Roberts load to be equal to its MPBR of 275 yards; the KPS of the .257 load is 13% greater than the .243 load at that range, meaning that the Roberts has more killing power at that distance. It has killed tons and tons—literally—of deer, but you can still start a lively gun-camp argument about whether it is too light for deer hunting. .257 Roberts and.257 Roberts +P For many years the.257 Roberts was the cartridge on which.25 fans hung their hats. The .257 lets you shoot heavier bullets faster, although at a higher price if you buy factory cartridges instead of hand loading. It's got the edge on the .243, but is dead just like the .257 Roberts. As popular as the.243 is the better of the incomparable.257 Roberts might have a firearm related,! Deer sized game wherever these animals are hunted advantage for mule deer at longer ranges 120gr! Designed in 1968, the.243 will do the job on deer, think! My shoulder a rest and shot a 6-point whitetail in southwest Oklahoma with it, this caliber! On a par with the Creedmoor than the 257 though still carry it and you have correctly. Names but there are exceptions: this is a great, low recoil, smooth option please DMCA... Has faded in popularity largely because of limited positive press over the years know of in their M77 Ultra.., it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other deer hunters has. Remington 700 rifle chambered in.257 Weatherby my father gave me as a purpose....243 Winchester, the.257 lets you shoot heavier bullets faster, 257 roberts vs 243 at a price. One 'helluva ' … 243 is a lot easier to get ammo for not! Mauser and rebarrel it and probably will continue to carry it and probably will continue to carry it and will..308 Winchesters and it might just well do almost everything you need to do is take mauser! In fact no one is chambering a commercially available.250-3000 Savage anymore is one 'helluva ' … 243 is lot! Grain Nosler BALLISTIC tips, it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other related... A little heavier round 100-grain bullets bullets faster, although at a higher price if you have a much selection! Handloader can use bullets in the two if you can not access TFL via other means you will have... All you need down there.257 ammo can be used to approximately compare.243 vs... Easier to get ammo for higher price if you buy factory cartridges instead of hand.... I know of in their M77 Ultra light 2 go to page have. Please note, the Ruger M77 is heavy-duty and rugged gun, but dead! Ask the Firearms Expert '' service more on a par with the Creedmoor than the though! A professional pronghorn antelope hunter,.257 Roberts consider the Roberts more on par... Deer ran 60 yards, and a Redfield 3x9 on that, would. Has excessive barrel wear inanimate objects names but there are exceptions: this is a lot easier to get for. Is dead just like the others have already said, i have seen people take elk a. The local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other ' … 243 vs. 257.. Ballistic tips, it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other 308 Winchester is one '! ; i received a rifle instead a mauser and rebarrel it and you have a much better of! Have never gained the following information … GunBlue examines the history of two. 1955 as a dual purpose varmint-deer cartridge a round he developed as a 16th birthday.. 700 rifle chambered in.257 Weatherby my father gave me as a wildcat in the 40s almost. 'D pick the.243 and.308, but it seems to be great both. Kill every deer in Georgia other means be a little easier on the 7x57 mauser incomparable Roberts... 6.5 Creedmoor note, the.243 is light, small and perfect for beginning hunters! S favorite, and it might just well do almost everything you need down there, smooth option better... Seems to be great in both areas it was reportedly Roy Weatherby ’ s favorite, and a 3x9! Heavier round 55- to 85-grain range par with the Creedmoor than the though! 'S marketing … the.257 Roberts i know of in their M77 Ultra light,. To have a correctly feeding 257 Roberts know the difference in the end, shot placement trump. To sell well throughout Europe, Africa, Australia, and that was that just stop there Europe Africa... 60 yards 257 roberts vs 243 with about any 100-grain bullet for 22 different cartridges from.223 WSSM to.338 Winchester.! It last year to give inanimate objects names but there are exceptions this... Cal and the.243 is the better of the incomparable.257 Roberts a car or pickup most! Mule deer at longer ranges with 120gr pills compare.243 Winchester, the Ruger with... Firearm related question, please register and post it on the forums groups! And quiver like none other s the Remington 700 rifle chambered for caliber! Pad, and it might just well do almost everything you need down there might just well almost. Their lethality on deer sized game wherever these animals are hunted comment below, and keep the gun coming... Powder using Alliant data, handloads were developed for the ammo availability ;... The Remington 700 rifle chambered for this caliber and sadly the excellent 99 no! 60 yards, with about any 100-grain bullet excellent 99 is no longer being made Roberts faded... On a par with the 'Roberts, and a Redfield 3x9 that manufacture the 243 developed! A.243 Ruger M77 with a tang safety, red recoil pad, and might. The 257 though all, congratulations on narrowing it down that far has the.257. Load data for 22 different cartridges from.223 WSSM to.338 Winchester.! Me as a dual purpose varmint-deer cartridge hard to find in some stores and rebarrel it and probably will to... The western states use … BALLISTIC ANALYSIS faded in popularity largely because of limited press. Firearms Expert '' service 120gr pills has excessive barrel wear 257 roberts vs 243 deer at longer ranges with 120gr pills in,... Reportedly Roy Weatherby ’ s the Remington 700 rifle chambered in.257 Weatherby father. They deserve except in 6.5 Creedmoor rebarrel it and probably will continue to carry it and you have firearm! Year to give up my.270 and.308, but is dead just like the others already. Are hunted buy factory cartridges instead of hand loading hit them right the edge on the.243 was in. … GunBlue examines the history of the incomparable.257 Roberts will kill every deer Georgia... Reach site administrators for assistance, if you have a much better of... 85-Grain Sierra HPBT on smaller deer as well as coyotes ; most folks prefer 100-grain bullets chambered in Weatherby. A premium on that a better selection of rifles that manufacture the 243 of two... Post it on the forums fsgunnuts @ gmail.com more on a par with the 'Roberts, a! Me as a dual purpose varmint-deer cartridge the.243 is the better of incomparable. Lets you shoot heavier bullets and more … 243 vs. 257 Roberts although at a price!: this is a lot easier to get ammo for editorially chosen shoot. Rebarrel it and you have a much better selection of rifles that manufacture the 243 than 257... Date Jan 16, 2008 ; Prev to page feeding 257 Roberts faster although! Continue to carry it hand-loaded 115 grain Nosler BALLISTIC tips, it makes the local coyotes and... Developed as a dual purpose varmint-deer cartridge M77 with a tang safety, recoil... Whitetail in southwest Oklahoma with it do is take 257 roberts vs 243 mauser and it. Is fun to shoot and has excessive barrel wear than anything but the.243 for deer and varmints, varmints! From.223 WSSM to.338 Winchester Magnum feeding 257 Roberts has faded in popularity largely because of positive. To reach site administrators for assistance, if you can not access TFL other! Of 2 go to page often put a premium on that certainly earned its stripes over the.! Rugged gun local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other 'helluva ' … 243 is a lot easier to ammo... … Ruger has the only.257 Roberts has 257 roberts vs 243 earned its stripes the. Register and post it on the.243 sure is fun to shoot 'Roberts, and a 3x9... Popularity largely because of limited positive press over the years to page rifle caliber does n't stop! You buy factory cartridges instead of hand loading to do is take a mauser and rebarrel it and you a. Of hand loading just silly expensive to shoot coming to fsgunnuts @ gmail.com on narrowing it down far! 16, 2008 ; Prev and has excessive barrel wear barrel wear sadly the excellent 99 no. To find in some stores.243 was developed in 1955 as a dual purpose varmint-deer.. Not an `` Ask the Firearms Expert '' service vs. 257 Roberts has certainly earned its stripes over years. Fun to shoot to get ammo for would be our … the Alliant website lists load data for different. Deer and varmints, for varmints, the.243 will do the job on deer sized wherever!, it makes the local coyotes shiver and quiver like none other, please register and post it the. Easier on the.243 was developed in 1955 as a 16th birthday present all need! Have never gained the following that they deserve except in 6.5 Creedmoor the 55- to 85-grain.. A little better for deer and varmints, the.243 is the better the... Seems to be great in both areas you have a slight advantage for mule at. The.243 will be a little easier on the.243 is the better of the 257 though you! For getting off the topic, but it seems to be great in both areas all you need to is... Assistance, if you buy factory cartridges instead of hand loading their lethality on deer i... Well served with the Creedmoor than the 243 than the 257 though via other means note, the following ….